The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[kittykatabcde]

Hello, uh, first time using this thread and. Help please?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105324786&userid=1060238&signature=3WaA5XN4ILuhsST7gZgUQg

Appreciate it; item worth is overall disorienting for me!

just at a glance, this is very unfair to you!
Even though some items were freely obtained via events, they're still worth 1 UC from their year. That's at least 1c$ per item, which they clearly aren't offering. This trade is again, very unfair to you.

i was thinking it was probably unfair with what offers i have gotten for individual things in the past and if im not mistaken this is /all/ of my items, so i appreciate the confirmation!!

[Lex.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105327549&userid=881933&signature=JyenjhzQtf2lh_IcYYZ9RA

is this fair??

Overpay on their side, 4 2021 rares do not add up to a 2010-11 rare [which iirc, is the base value of newer store pets, pretty sure it's 2010]

@kittykatabcde : ofc! glad to have helped.

[kijauni]

It's me again^^
Is it fair item wise with the Coontail trade? Would my side be over/underpaying? I am still a confused nugget

Coontail for bulk rares + Store Pets + Malk Elementals + 3 TD Zodiacs + Candycane Horse + Items -> I would need help with the Items Part as I never have been that good with them. Especially the full Sun Plushie Set and the Animal Egg 12 is making me think about the value of them^^

Additionally I have a medium (?) speckled rat as offer for 2 Malk Elementals

even tho the trade is now cancelled, I'd still like to know, if it would have been fair

[Lex.]

It's me again^^
Is it fair item wise with the raccoontail trade? Would my side be over/underpaying? I am still a confused nugget :oops:

Racoontail for bulk rares + Store Pets + Malk Elementals + 3 TD Zodiacs + Candycane Horse + Items -> I would need help with the Items Part as I never have been that good with them. Especially the full Sun Plushie Set and the Animal Egg 12 is making me think about the value of them^^

Additionally I have a medium (?) speckled rat as offer for 2 Malk Elementals

even tho the trade is now cancelled, I'd still like to know, if it would have been fair :D

The Light Speckled Rat for the 2 Elementals wouldn't have been fair for the rat, the Light Speckled is worth at least 3 MA, and at most 5-7.

For the 1st trade:

Raccoontail: 1.5-2n

Elementals: 1 MA each so 3 MA
Candy Cane Tess Horse: .5-.75 MA
x3 Zodiacs = 1.5~ MA
Monster Plush: .5 MA
Rat Plush: .5 MA
Dog Plushes : 4 MA total
1 MA added together for the other items
18.5 09 rares = 2.5 MAs

13.5 MAs total on your side, which is just over 1 non which would've been unfair to them. Even the rare items are pushing in terms of value, they're hard enough to trade off as it is.

[stellarzorua]

hello! i didnt see this trade until it was already cancelled but I just wanted to check if y’all think it was fair? I’m not good with c$ values!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105307015&userid=464150&signature=QNa2Rf3hd-WA-aQhk9N_kg

[Lex.]

hello! i didnt see this trade until it was already cancelled but I just wanted to check if y’all think it was fair? I’m not good with c$ values!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105307015&userid=464150&signature=QNa2Rf3hd-WA-aQhk9N_kg

That store set's pets get .5 MA each, so the 250c$ would've been overpay by itself, but tbh it's a good value since store pets do have more demand and people value them much higher.

[Mistwing]

Is this trade fair?

[Lex.]

Is this trade fair?

Regardless of if your unknown rarity pets become UC or not, this looks fair, maybe more overpay on the other users side. It's easy date math, 2023 C = 2023 C, just depends on the pets you want for your pets.

[Mistwing]

Is this trade fair?

Regardless of if your unknown rarity pets become UC or not, this looks fair, maybe more overpay on the other users side. It's easy date math, 2023 C = 2023 C, just depends on the pets you want for your pets.

Thanks!

---------------------------

Can I get a second opinion, please?

[teariffic]

Is this trade fair?

Regardless of if your unknown rarity pets become UC or not, this looks fair, maybe more overpay on the other users side. It's easy date math, 2023 C = 2023 C, just depends on the pets you want for your pets.

Thanks!

---------------------------

Can I get a second opinion, please?

it would be slight overpay on the side w/ no still growing pets ! same reasons as the previous user gave - it's pretty simple common for common and they threw in some extra